TheLeaflet
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Why Leaflet
    • Leaflet Team
  • Constitutional Law
  • Human Rights
  • Culture
    • Book Review
    • Movie Review
    • Poetry
  • Humour
  • Issues
    • Analysis
    • Case update
    • Child’s Rights
    • Civil Law
    • Coronavirus and the Law
    • Criminal Justice System
    • Criminal Law
    • Dalit Rights
    • Editor’s Desk
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Fundamental Rights
    • Gender Rights
    • Governance
    • Health Rights
    • History
    • International Law
    • Judiciary
    • Juvenile Justice
    • Know Your Rights
    • Labour Law
    • Law and Technology
    • Litigation
    • Mental Health
    • Policy
    • Politics
    • Right To Informtion
    • Sexual Offences
    • Social Justice
  • Leaflet Specials
    • Independence Day Special
    • Independence of judiciary
    • Right to Privacy
    • Special Issue: Emergency
    • The legacy of Ruth Ginsburg
    • Triple Talaq
    • Two years since Navtej Johar case
  • Videos
  • Historical Series
  • Contact us
    • Write For Us
    • Careers
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Why Leaflet
    • Leaflet Team
  • Constitutional Law
  • Human Rights
  • Culture
    • Book Review
    • Movie Review
    • Poetry
  • Humour
  • Issues
    • Analysis
    • Case update
    • Child’s Rights
    • Civil Law
    • Coronavirus and the Law
    • Criminal Justice System
    • Criminal Law
    • Dalit Rights
    • Editor’s Desk
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Fundamental Rights
    • Gender Rights
    • Governance
    • Health Rights
    • History
    • International Law
    • Judiciary
    • Juvenile Justice
    • Know Your Rights
    • Labour Law
    • Law and Technology
    • Litigation
    • Mental Health
    • Policy
    • Politics
    • Right To Informtion
    • Sexual Offences
    • Social Justice
  • Leaflet Specials
    • Independence Day Special
    • Independence of judiciary
    • Right to Privacy
    • Special Issue: Emergency
    • The legacy of Ruth Ginsburg
    • Triple Talaq
    • Two years since Navtej Johar case
  • Videos
  • Historical Series
  • Contact us
    • Write For Us
    • Careers
No Result
View All Result
TheLeaflet
No Result
View All Result
in International Law

Triumph of International Law

Prannv DhawanbyPrannv Dhawan
July 27, 2019
in International Law
Triumph of International Law

[dropcap]T[/dropcap]HE final verdict of the International Court of Justice, the apex judicial body of the United Nations, has given a glimmer of hope for the just and humane treatment of retired Navy officer Kulbhushan Jadhav.

While the Indian diplomatic and legal leadership is justifiably lauding it as a ‘decisive’ geopolitical triumph that has resulted from concerted and coherent team effort, the verdict has also become a harbinger of hope and sanity for the multitudes of prisoners whose lives have been on the brink of uncertainty due to the contested terrain of India-Pakistan animosity.

Even though there have been several positive developments in the recent past where India and Pakistan have repatriated prisoners as a goodwill measure, this judgment has the potential to foreground the human rights of these prisoners under international law who often become subjects of the pernicious loop of competitive jingoism. Beyond the cries of victory, the real winner to emerge from the International Court of Justice’s decision is the very idea of international law.

Earlier this week, the court decided in India’s favour in the case of India vs Pakistan. Only one Judge, Justice Gillani, ad hoc Judge dissented- the other 15 agreed with most of India’s arguments in principle. The court ruled that it had jurisdiction in the case, and additionally that the Republic of Pakistan violated the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations. The court opined, “the court is of the view that Pakistan is under an obligation to cease those acts and to comply fully with its obligations under Article 36 of the Vienna Convention. Consequently, Pakistan must inform Mr Jadhav without further delay of his rights under Article 36, paragraph 1 (b), and allow Indian consular officers to have access to him and to arrange for his legal representation…”.

The ICJ has also obligated Pakistan to undertake an “effective review and reconsideration” of the conviction and sentence of Jadhav through means of its choosing, which could include enacting an appropriate legislation. However, ICJ has emphasised that this review shall be effective only if Pakistan gives full weight to the adverse consequences and prejudices that have resulted from Pakistan’s non-compliance of Article 36 of VCCR.

 

Enforceability of ICJ’s decisions

 

The ICJ was established to settle international legal disputes. The court’s decisions are binding on member states but concerns about their practical enforceability have been raised. A study about the enforceability of the final verdicts concluded that in recent years, while there was hardly any direct defiance of the ICJ’s judgements, a few of them met with less compliance than others due to complicated realpolitiks.

The ball, therefore, is now in Pakistan’s court as to how it implements the ICJ ruling both in letter and spirit. Under Article 94(1) of the United Nations Charter, Pakistan is under an obligation to comply with this ruling.

Regardless of how heinous the crime every defendant has the right to legal counsel. Pakistan, similarly, must ensure this right is given to the accused. The trial should also be fair and follow well-established principles of international law and convention.

Additionally, the Joint Judicial Committee on Prisoners should be politically and diplomatically empowered to provide for a comprehensive charter of rights for prisoners and protocols to be enforced on domestic law enforcement institutions. The bilateral dialogue must highlight the urgent need to safeguard the human rights of all individuals so that both India and Pakistan can emerge as law-abiding and civilised countries among the comity of nations.

 

Prannv Dhawan is a student of National Law School of India University. He is a senior member of the Council of International Relations and International Law and has volunteered with CHRI Prisoners Rights initiative.

Related Posts

Violations of Rights and Compensation: India’s Failure to Adhere to International Standards
Analysis

Violations of Rights and Compensation: India’s Failure to Adhere to International Standards

byRavi Nair
Singapore Convention on Mediation enters into force
International Law

Singapore Convention on Mediation enters into force

byThe Leaflet
WANTED:  A Robust Legal Regime for Regulating Space Traffic
International Law

WANTED: A Robust Legal Regime for Regulating Space Traffic

bySyed Tamjeed Ahmad

Editor's Pick

Can the State Dictate what Religion you will Follow and who you will Marry?

Can the State Dictate what Religion you will Follow and who you will Marry?

byIndira Jaising

India’s Polarised Media Reflects Crisis of Confidence in its Politics

India’s Polarised Media Reflects Crisis of Confidence in its Politics

byRevathi Siva Kumar

Munawar Faruqui:  Real Villain is Divisive Heartland Politics, Not Stand-up Comics

Munawar Faruqui: Real Villain is Divisive Heartland Politics, Not Stand-up Comics

byParsa Venkateshwar Rao Jr

Dilip Chhabria made crores designing cars, then why did he design creative ways to defraud banks?

Dilip Chhabria made crores designing cars, then why did he design creative ways to defraud banks?

byRamesh Menon

Latest by TheLeaflet

Opposition unity crucial in Budget Session 2021

January 20, 2021
As Assam pushes to produce rubber, India may be less dependent on imports

As Assam pushes to produce rubber, India may be less dependent on imports

January 20, 2021
Historical Series: Justice Harilal Kania and The Criminal Contempt Case of 1942

Bombay HC sets free woman detained by parents for her relationship with Muslim man

January 20, 2021
Bar Council of India demands free laptops, iPads, WiFi for needy lawyers

BCI steps towards exclusivity and elitism by favouring 3-year experience at the Bar for judicial services exam

January 20, 2021

Newsletter

Subscribe to our mailing list to receives daily updates direct to your inbox!

Follow Us

© 2020 TheLeaflet

SUBSCRIBE FOR UPDATES
×

Subscribe to The Leaflet

Enter your email address to subscribe to The Leaflet and receive notifications of new posts by email.

  • Home
  • About Us
    • Why Leaflet
    • Leaflet Team
  • Constitutional Law
  • Human Rights
  • Culture
    • Book Review
    • Movie Review
    • Poetry
  • Humour
  • Issues
    • Analysis
    • Case update
    • Child’s Rights
    • Civil Law
    • Coronavirus and the Law
    • Criminal Justice System
    • Criminal Law
    • Dalit Rights
    • Editor’s Desk
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Fundamental Rights
    • Gender Rights
    • Governance
    • Health Rights
    • History
    • International Law
    • Judiciary
    • Juvenile Justice
    • Know Your Rights
    • Labour Law
    • Law and Technology
    • Litigation
    • Mental Health
    • Policy
    • Politics
    • Right To Informtion
    • Sexual Offences
    • Social Justice
  • Leaflet Specials
    • Independence Day Special
    • Independence of judiciary
    • Right to Privacy
    • Special Issue: Emergency
    • The legacy of Ruth Ginsburg
    • Triple Talaq
    • Two years since Navtej Johar case
  • Videos
  • Historical Series
  • Contact us
    • Write For Us
    • Careers

© 2020 TheLeaflet